AlterNet / By Janet Allon
Paul Krugman Exposes the Folly of Running the Country Like a Business
Why would a country hand over its ailing economy to corporate interests?
November 3, 2014 |
America holds its corporate chieftains in such high regard that it looks to them to solve the country's most dire economic problems. This does not always work out. Paul Krugman analyzes why in his column Monday.
Krugman begins by looking at Japan, where the central bank announced more aggressive money measures to fight deflation last week, a move which Krugman supports and Japan's business elite adamantly opposes. Krugman takes the opportunity to examine the whole question of "the economic wisdom, or lack thereof, of business leaders."
Some of the people I’ve spoken to here argue that the opposition of many Japanese business leaders to the Bank of Japan’s actions shows that it’s on the wrong track. In saying this, they’re echoing a common sentiment in many countries, including America — the belief that if you want to fix an ailing economy, you should turn to people who have been successful in business, like leaders of major corporations, entrepreneurs and wealthy investors. After all, doesn’t their success with money mean that they know how the economy really works?
Actually, no. In fact, business leaders often give remarkably bad economic advice, especially in troubled times. And I think it’s important to understand why.
Krugman scores point after point as he illuminates just how wrong wealthy money managers and corporate chieftains have been about monetary policy in this country. When the Fed tried to boost the economy by printing more money, these business interests frantically warned about currency debasement, and hyperinflation, neither of which ever arrived. They harped away on fixing the debt and cutting spending as ways to grow the economy. Did. Not. Work.
On the other hand, when decisions have been left to economists with more academic credentials as opposed to business success—like Ben Bernanke, Janet Yellen, Mervyn King, and in Europe, Mario Draghi—who have ignored or defied the advice of business leaders, things have gone a bit better. Still, Krugman hastens to point out, "Obviously there are business leaders who have gotten the economic analysis right, and plenty of academics who have gotten it wrong. (Don’t get me started.) But success in business does not seem to convey any special insight into economic policy. Why?"
The reason, in a nutshell, is contained in paper Krugman wrote many years ago. A country is not a company. He writes:
Think of what happens when a successful businessperson looks at a troubled economy and tries to apply the lessons of business experience. He or (rarely) she sees the troubled economy as something like a troubled company, which needs to cut costs and become competitive. To create jobs, the businessperson thinks, wages must come down, expenses must be reduced; in general, belts must be tightened. And surely gimmicks like deficit spending or printing more money can’t solve what must be a fundamental problem.
In reality, however, cutting wages and spending in a depressed economy just aggravates the real problem, which is inadequate demand. Deficit spending and aggressive money-printing, on the other hand, can help a lot.
A country that lets its corporate leaders call the shots is on a path to ruin. Listen up Japan. And us.
Blogs by Hanching Chung
- ► 2017 (195)
- ► 2016 (312)
- ► 2015 (489)
- 企業、政黨的 接班困境
- 華隆案終於達成共識 退休金將全額清償「華隆罷工第77天」101天的堅持 、收到第一期款項
- 美國密蘇里Ferguson 種族衝突的一些教訓
- Fairlife from Coca-Cola
- DuPont Pressured to Sell or Spin Off Ag Business 2...
- 英國小報照片「重鹹」 超市將設「遮羞架」
- The Real Apple Store / HR meets science at Google ...
- 食安法修法 消基會批沒修到精髓
- 如何用統計說謊(于國欽) ；中韓FTA簽了台灣就死？只有腦殘政府和媽寶企業，會把「零關稅」當成競爭力...
- 彭博調查：油價狂跌 對俄羅斯打擊最大
- 沾頂新椰子油 公布拖拖拉拉/衛福部被批包庇統一
- 韓中締結FTA ：南韓企業為何笑不出來？韓產業得失概觀 (楊虔豪)；童子賢：台灣最需要什麼？在享受零...
- save Social Security 養老金改革反思 Rethinking Pension R...
- 中美同意擴大ITA（Information Technology Agreement，資訊科技協定）...
- 南僑結盟一銀 產品全面進行溯源油.......品全過關.......食藥署堅持：南僑報關不實 暫不能...
- 投資：台中國家歌劇院 古典玫瑰園
- 中國 五年內完成品種更新換代；靠“大肥大水”的高耗水高化肥的糧食生產方式需要改變
- 柯營： 民主選舉為何搞竊聽
- Ford new aluminium-bodied F-150 pickup truck
- 韓2車廠誇大省油被重罰 Hyundai Motor Company and the Kia Moto...
- 企業家常是差勁的經濟政策者Paul Krugman Exposes the Folly of Run...
- 正義黑心豬油 全台691通路完整版曝光
- HC短評；Safe Quality Food、HACCP系統 ；詹岳霖：台灣食品產業大串聯 「向上管...
- ▼ 十一月 (42)
- ► 2013 (180)
- ► 2012 (275)
- ► 2011 (274)
- ► 2010 (170)
- ► 2009 (168)
- ► 2008 (214)